Thursday, January 26, 2023
Cannabis News Daily
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Cannabis News
  • Medical Marijuana
  • Legalization
  • Cannabis Business
  • Cannabis Laws
  • Cannabis Retail
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Cannabis News
  • Medical Marijuana
  • Legalization
  • Cannabis Business
  • Cannabis Laws
  • Cannabis Retail
No Result
View All Result
Cannabis News Daily
No Result
View All Result
Home Medical Marijuana

Justice Thomas rightly questions federal marijuana authority – Orange County Register

cannabisnews by cannabisnews
July 9, 2021
in Medical Marijuana
0
Justice Thomas rightly questions federal marijuana authority – Orange County Register
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court decided not to hear an appeal from the owners of a Colorado marijuana business, not because they didn’t have a good case, but rather, because they did.

We know this because Justice Clarence Thomas chose to write a statement about the court’s denial of the petition for a writ of certiorari. “A prohibition on intrastate use or cultivation of marijuana may no longer be necessary or proper,” he concluded.

The owners of Standing Akimbo Medical Dispensary were challenging a provision of the federal tax code that limits tax deductions for companies that deal in controlled substances prohibited by federal law. Under the federal rules, marijuana businesses may deduct from their taxable income only the cost of goods sold, not ordinary business expenses such as rent, utilities and employee salaries. The business owners argued that this makes the tax unconstitutional.

Thomas wrote in a footnote that their argument “implicates several difficult questions, including the differences between ‘direct’ and ‘indirect’ taxes and how to interpret the Sixteenth Amendment.” He said he agreed with “the Court’s decision not to delve into these questions.”

But the constitutional amendment that sheds the most light on this case isn’t the Sixteenth, which established the income tax. It’s the Eighteenth, which enacted a federal ban on the manufacture, sale or transportation of intoxicating liquors.

The Prohibition amendment, and the 21st Amendment repealing Prohibition in 1933, stand as witnesses to the fact that the federal government did not have the power under the Constitution to ban alcohol. The states had to approve an amendment to the Constitution to enact it, and to reverse it.

Why is marijuana different than alcohol?Ducking this question, the Supreme Court relied on complicated and disputed reasoning in the 2005 case of Gonzales v. Raich. A divided court held that Congress’ power to regulate interstate commerce gave it the power to prohibit marijuana use within a state’s borders. The majority found that the federal prohibition on intrastate use of marijuana was “necessary and proper” to avoid creating a “gaping hole” in Congress’ “closed regulatory system.”

Justice Thomas has now pointed out that this “closed” system is full of openings. Thirty-six states allow medicinal marijuana use and 18 states allow recreational use as well. In 2009, Congress itself allowed Washington D.C.’s government to decriminalize medical marijuana under a local ordinance. Further, Congress has prohibited the Department of Justice from “spending funds to prevent states’ implementation of their own medical marijuana laws” every year since 2015.

“The federal government’s current approach to marijuana bears little resemblance to the watertight nationwide prohibition that a closely divided Court found necessary to justify the Government’s blanket prohibition in Raich,” Thomas wrote.

The manufacture, distribution or possession of marijuana remains a federal criminal offense as long as it is listed as a prohibited Schedule I drug under the Controlled Substances Act. Congress could change that, but so far has not.

Justice Thomas’s statement hints at the possibility that the Supreme Court would hear a case that tees up the constitutional issue for a landmark decision. Quoting from Justice Sandra Day O’Connor’s dissenting opinion in the Raich case, Thomas wrote that the federal government “might no longer have authority to intrude on the States’ core police powers…to define criminal law and protect the health, safety and welfare of their citizens.”



Source link

RELATED POSTS

Tribes wary of cannabis market opening

Medical Marijuana May Not Aid Pain, Anxiety, Depression Symptoms

ShareTweetPin
cannabisnews

cannabisnews

Related Posts

Tribes wary of cannabis market opening

Tribes wary of cannabis market opening

by cannabisnews
March 26, 2022
0

Two hundred hydroponic cannabis plants grow in a room filled with artificial sunlight at High Desert Relief in Albuquerque...

Medical Marijuana May Not Aid Pain, Anxiety, Depression Symptoms

Medical Marijuana May Not Aid Pain, Anxiety, Depression Symptoms

by cannabisnews
March 26, 2022
0

FRIDAY, March 25, 2022 (HealthDay News) — Immediate access to medical marijuana cards may have negative consequences, including higher...

Tennessee bill creating framework for medical marijuana program passes House subcommittee

Tennessee bill creating framework for medical marijuana program passes House subcommittee

by cannabisnews
March 26, 2022
0

The House of Representatives Health Committee will discuss the bill on Wednesday. NASHVILLE, Tenn. — A Tennessee bill that...

Jefferson to Consider Ambulance Increase, Medical Marijuana Ordinance

Jefferson to Consider Ambulance Increase, Medical Marijuana Ordinance

by cannabisnews
March 25, 2022
0

Jefferson residents will vote on a 1,002.74% increase to fund emergency medical services, a new medical marijuana ordinance, and...

Colorado Earned $423 Million In Marijuana Tax Revenue Last Year

Missouri Bill Would Let Voters Mandate More Oversight On Medical Marijuana Revenue Distribution To Veterans

by cannabisnews
March 25, 2022
0

The Senate on Thursday unanimously approved a marijuana bill—but not the federal legalization measure that advocates have been eagerly...

Next Post
Opinion | Michael Pollan: Legalizing Drugs Means Answering New Questions

Opinion | Michael Pollan: Legalizing Drugs Means Answering New Questions

Northern NY Indian tribe on track to open state’s first legal marijuana shops

Northern NY Indian tribe on track to open state’s first legal marijuana shops

RECOMMENDED

Valley News – Column: Small producers deserve direct access to market

Valley News – Column: Small producers deserve direct access to market

March 26, 2022

Decriminalization: The pathway to legalization and cannabis equity | Nikki Fried – South Florida Sun Sentinel

March 26, 2022
  • 22M Fans
  • 121 Followers
  • 650 Followers
  • 23.7k Followers

MOST VIEWED

  • US Hemp and Cannabis Industry Leaders to Participate with Government at Event Celebrating New Legalization In Costa Rica

    US Hemp and Cannabis Industry Leaders to Participate with Government at Event Celebrating New Legalization In Costa Rica

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Oklahoma Cannabis Pioneer Joins Forces with Budding Cannabis Brand Ganja Goat Guru

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • New Jersey Begins Accepting Recreational Cannabis License Applications: When Will Dispensaries Open?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Federal Marijuana Legalization Bill May Receive House Floor Vote Next Week, Sources Say

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Legalizing recreational marijuana in Florida

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Recent News

Valley News – Column: Small producers deserve direct access to market

Valley News – Column: Small producers deserve direct access to market

March 26, 2022

Decriminalization: The pathway to legalization and cannabis equity | Nikki Fried – South Florida Sun Sentinel

March 26, 2022
Will SAFE Banking Act help?

Will SAFE Banking Act help?

March 26, 2022

CATEGORY

  • Cannabis Business
  • Cannabis Laws
  • Cannabis News
  • Cannabis Retail
  • Legalization
  • Medical Marijuana

Contact Us

  • Privacy & Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

© 2021 Copyright Cannabis News Daily

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Cannabis News
  • Medical Marijuana
  • Legalization
  • Cannabis Business
  • Cannabis Laws
  • Cannabis Retail

© 2021 Copyright Cannabis News Daily